Invoice Finance vs Merchant Cash Advance: What's the Difference?
Invoice finance advances cash against your unpaid B2B invoices. Merchant cash advances provide a lump sum repaid as a percentage of daily card takings. Invoice finance suits B2B businesses invoicing on credit. MCAs suit retail, hospitality, and e-commerce businesses taking card payments.
| Invoice finance | Merchant cash advance | |
|---|---|---|
| Funds against | Unpaid invoices to business customers | Future card or terminal takings |
| Suits | Businesses that invoice other businesses on credit terms | Retail, hospitality and online businesses taking card payments |
| How much | A lump sum based on your card takings | |
| Cost | Usually a service charge plus a discount charge on the money you draw, set by each lender | A fixed total to repay, set by a factor rate (a factor of 1.3 on £10,000 means £13,000 to repay) |
| Repayment | From your customers' payments | An agreed share of each day's card takings until the total is repaid |
Why This Matters
The two products fit different businesses. Invoice finance needs unpaid invoices from business customers. An MCA needs steady card takings. A shop with no invoices cannot use invoice finance, and a business paid mostly by bank transfer gets little from an MCA, because the repayments come out of card takings.
Key Points
- Invoice finance: the lender advances part of each invoice and pays you the rest, less its charges, when your customer pays. Lenders usually take security over the invoices and often ask for a personal guarantee.
- MCA: many providers set it up as buying a share of your future card sales rather than lending to you. You repay a fixed total, however quickly or slowly that happens.
- A factor rate is not an interest rate. Because the total is fixed, the faster you repay, the higher the cost works out as a yearly rate. Ask the provider for the total cost and the expected repayment period, and compare like with like.
- Check each provider on the FCA register and ask what protection applies to your agreement before you sign either product.
- Each provider sets its own minimum turnover, card takings or invoice levels, so check each one's criteria.
Illustrative Example
Hypothetical, with assumed figures: a design agency that invoices £80,000 a month to business clients on 45-day terms, and a coffee shop that takes £40,000 a month in card payments.
The agency uses confidential invoice discounting. Assume its lender advances 85% (£68,000) and its charges come to 1.2% of that a month (about £816). The coffee shop has no invoices, so it takes an MCA. Assume a £30,000 advance at a 1.35 factor rate, so £40,500 to repay, with 15% of card takings going to the provider. At £40,000 a month in card takings that is £6,000 a month, so the advance is repaid in about 7 months, at a cost of £10,500. The real figures depend on each provider's quote.
Common Pitfalls
- Applying for invoice finance with no invoices to business customers. Lenders need unpaid invoices to fund against, not forecasts of card sales.
- Taking an MCA when most of your income arrives by bank transfer. The daily deductions come out of a small part of your income and can squeeze your cash.
- Reading a factor rate as an interest rate. A 1.3 factor repaid over a few months costs far more as a yearly rate than 30%.
- Taking more than one facility without reading the terms. Many agreements restrict other borrowing, and breaking that can mean repaying at once.
What to Do Next
- Look at where your income came from over the last few months: invoices to businesses, card takings or both.
- If you get MCA quotes, ask for the total repayable and the daily deduction, and check you can manage that deduction on your quietest days.
- If you get invoice finance quotes, ask for the advance rate, every fee and the notice period, and work out the monthly cost on your usual invoices.
Related Questions
Can I use invoice finance if I also take card payments?
Yes. Invoice finance is based on invoices to business customers, so card takings do not count towards it, but they do not stop you using it either. Businesses with a mix of invoiced work and card sales can fund the invoiced part.
How are merchant cash advances regulated in the UK?
Many are set up as a purchase of your future card takings rather than a loan, so they may fall outside the FCA's credit rules. Check the contract, and check the provider on the FCA register, before you sign.
Which is faster to set up, invoice finance or an MCA?
It depends on the provider. An MCA is judged mainly on your card takings history. Invoice finance means the lender also checks your customers and sets up the facility, which can take longer the first time. Once a facility is running, you can draw against new invoices as you raise them. Ask each provider for its timings.
Can I switch from an MCA to invoice finance later?
Usually, if you invoice business customers. Check your MCA contract first: it may restrict other borrowing until it is repaid, and an invoice finance lender will ask what other finance you have.
Founder & Managing Director, Muswell Rose, founder and PSC of Best Business Loans Ltd
Adam was managing director of Penny, a UK invoice finance business, from July 2020 to November 2023. His career runs through insurance, mortgages, commercial finance and fintech lending. He writes the Market Invoice library. Career record.
Last updated: